If you ask college admissions officers how they make decisions, most will tell you the first thing they look at is the rigor of the student’s curriculum. For selective colleges, this means Advanced Placement (AP) courses, which give high school students the opportunity to do college-level work. With competition for college admission increasing every year, many students fear they won’t be accepted without at least five or six AP courses, and when it comes to the most selective colleges, they are probably right.
A student’s curriculum is evaluated in the context of that high school, so if ten AP courses are offered and a student has only taken one, admissions officers at selective colleges will wonder why. But if a high school only offers a couple of AP courses, students can’t be expected to take classes that don’t exist, and they would not be at a disadvantage in the admissions process, though they could enhance their applications by taking community college courses.
Students earn an extra point in AP classes, making a “B” in an AP course equal to an “A” in a regular class when the high school GPA is calculated. Colleges normally give special consideration to AP and honors courses in admissions decisions, but the way they treat these courses varies. Many colleges recalculate the GPA, and some schools un-weight the extra points for AP courses, but they do note that the student has taken challenging classes. Other colleges give the extra point for every AP course.
At almost every college information session, a parent will ask, “Is it better to get a “B” in an AP class or an “A” in a regular class?” The admissions officer answers, “It’s better to get an “A” in an AP class,” and everyone moans. It is true that students who are applying to the most prestigious schools need a stellar transcript, since the average GPA at those schools is over 4.0. But, as always, I want to remind students and parents that there are many fine schools that accept students who have just one or two AP courses and good but not great grades. I have also seen students admitted to some University of California campuses without any AP courses.
Students who have successfully completed several AP courses often find they are well-prepared for a college workload. AP courses can also give students a head start on college credit, if they do well on AP exams. Most students use their AP credits to place out of introductory courses. Students also have the flexibility to double-major or take a lighter class schedule while doing an internship.
Clearly, there are benefits to taking AP courses. Up to a point. Preparing for college is important, but so is preserving mental health. I advise my students to take the most challenging curriculum they can handle without having a nervous breakdown. I suggest they take AP courses in the subjects they are strongest in, and not worry about taking every AP course offered at their school. Someone who loves English and history but struggles with math and science doesn’t need to suffer through AP Physics.
Admissions officers like to see intellectual curiosity, but they also want students who will contribute to the college community. That means making time for extracurricular activities, community service or other interests. While it’s important to take on academic challenges, students who also spend time discovering and pursuing their passions will be attractive to colleges. They are also more likely to create satisfying lives.